These items are coded to be felt the same way by everyone unless stated otherwise in their coding. Some items might be listed twice in separate categories because in one it might have been listed as a type and in the other it was listed as the item itself.
Gifts[]
Universal Love[]
Prismatic Shard, Rabbit's Foot, Golden Pumpkin, Pearl, and Magic Rock Candy.
Universal Like[]
Emerald, Aquamarine, Ruby, Amethyst, Topaz, Jade, Diamond, Quartz, Fire Quartz, Frozen Tear, Earth Crystal, All Food Recipes, Pale Ale, Mayonnaise, Duck Mayonnaise, Honey, Pickles, Jelly, Beer, Wine, Juice, Cheese, Goat Cheese, Cloth, Truffle Oil, All Vegetables/Fruit, All Flowers, Coffee, Maple Syrup.
Universal Neutral[]
Fried Egg, Bread, Wheat, Hops.
Universal Dislike[]
All Fish, All Crafting Items, All Minerals, Copper Bar, Iron Bar, Gold Bar, Iridium Bar, Refined Quartz, All ore, Coal, Wood, Stone, Clay, Hardwood, Fiber, Battery Pack, All Fertilizer/Retaining Soil/Speed-Gro, All Fishing bobbers and hooks, All Monster Loot, All Seeds, Cave Carrot, Driftwood, Wheat Flour, Oil, Void Egg, Vinegar, Rice, All Geodes, Oak Resin, Pine Tar.
Universal Hate[]
Weeds, Joja Cola, All Trash, Red Mushroom, Rotten Plants, All Bait, Magnet, Sap, All Artifacts, Fish, Seaweed, All Algae, Hay, Poppy, Sea Urchin, Bug Meat, Snail, Slime, Oil of Garlic, Strange Bun, Void Mayonnaise
Exceptions[]
Haley hates Prismatic Shard, and dislikes Blackberries.
Penny hates Rabbit's Foot and Golden Pumpkin.
Caroline, Jas, Sebastian, and Sam dislike Mayonnaise.
Elliot dislikes Limestone and Tiger's Eye.
Emily dislikes Pine Tar, Ice Cream, and Sashimi.
Evelyn and Kent dislike Sashimi.
George dislikes all flowers except Daffodil.
Clint dislikes most flowers.
Jas, Sebastian, and Vincent dislike Jelly.
Jas and Vincent hate all Artisan Goods.
Krobus dislikes all Artisan Goods.
Maru dislikes Maple Syrup and is neutral towards Cranberries and Daffodils.
Maru, Shane, and Sam dislike Pickles.
Pierre dislikes every gem but Diamond.
Sebastian dislikes Pale Ale, Beer, Mead, Omelet, Dandelion, Cheese, and most flowers.
Willy dislikes all Cooking aside from dishes with fish in them, except for Sashimi, which he dislikes.
Elliot loves Duck Feathers.
Sebastian and Krobus love Void Eggs.
Wizard loves Solar and Void Essences.
Clint and Dwarf love Omni Geodes.
Sebastian and Abigail like Quartz, Leah does not.
Leah likes Driftwood only after 8 heart event.
Willy likes many types of fish.
Linus likes many types of fish.
Krobus loves Void Mayonnaise.
Leah, Marnie, Sam, and Shane dislike Seaweed.
Penny dislikes Red Mushrooms.
Abigail dislikes Vegetables.